| Date | Station Name | Notes |
| 1866 | Toms River | 1st station built west side of river, converted to freight house 1868, destroyed in gunpowder explosion 1874; 2nd station west side of river 1868, converted to freight station 1900; 3rd station built 1900, sold 1950, burned 1976; Turntable built 1866, removed 1885 |
| 1868 | Toms River Freight Station | Built 1868, retired 1973; still standing |
| 1915 | Beachwood | Built by Beachwood Property Owners; razed 1955 |
| 1882 | Beachwood Tower | Built by PRR 1882, closed 1948, razed 1950 |
| 1872 | Bayville | Renamed Barnegat Park 1888 & new station built; renamed Barnegat Park-Pinewald 1912; renamed Pinewald 1921, new station built, razed 1974 |
| 1872 | Cedar Creek | Renamed Lanoka 1895; renamed Lanoka Harbor 1923; station burned 1888, rebuilt 1900, razed 1954 |
| 1900 | Lanoka Freight Station | Built 1900, retired 1938, razed 1954 |
| 1872 | Forked River | New station built 1913, razed 1954 |
| 1888 | Ostrom | New station built 1896, discontinued in 1927 |
| 1872 | Waretown | New station built 1900, sold 1955, still in existence |
| 1872 | Barnegat Junction | Renamed Waretown Junction 1879 & station discontinued; Interlocking with Tuckerton RR built 1908, removed 1937 |
| 1879 | Barnegat | New station built 1910, sold 1949; turntable built 1879, retired 1954 |
| 1888 | Barnegat Freight Station | Built 1888, razed 1973 |